Sunday, July 31, 2011
Dinstinctions and Types: Folk Narratives from Oral Traditions
"Folklore scholars divide folk narrative into a variety of different general categories. Fairy tales (also called simply folktales) usually involve magical or supernatural characters or powers, are typically set in a nonhistorical time, and often accounced by some sort of disclaimer or marker that the tale is fictional. English speakers are most familiar with the formula "Once upon a time . . .". In Arabic dozens of such formulas are used in different regions, but one particularly famous one is Kan Wa-ma Kan ("There was and there was not")" (87).
Examples: Om al Manakhel, Hadeed Hadeedoo, Om Hamar (sort of), Hassan and the Jewels, The Golden Cow, Hamada and the Fairy Fish.
"Another major category of folk narrative is the legend and the primary distinction between the folktake and the legend for folklorists is that legends are usually told as if they were historically true, and often some members of the audience or the teller in fact accepts them as true. Legends are usually told as having taken place in a known physical location, sometimes even a specific time period, and are often linked to some element of modern reality--a simple example might be a story that tells how a particular local cliff or rock came to be known as 'Lover's Leap'" (87).
Example: The Legend of Mai and Ghaillan
Saturday, July 30, 2011
The Oldest Version of Cinderella
The Story of the Jinn-The supernatural and the Quran
Existence
The Jinn are beings created with free will, living on earth in a world parallel to mankind. The Arabic word Jinn is from the verb Janna which means to hide or conceal. Thus, they are physically invisible from man as their description suggests. This invisibility is one of the reasons why some people have denied their existence. However, (as will be seen) the affect which the world of the Jinn has upon our world, is enough to refute this modern denial of one of Gods creation. The origins of the Jinn can be traced from the Quran and the Sunnah. God says:
Indeed We created man from dried clay of black smooth mud. And We created the Jinn before that from the smokeless flame of fire (Quran 15:26-27)
Thus the Jinn were created before man. As for their physical origin, then the Prophet, may the mercy and blessings of God be upon him, has confirmed the above verse when he said:
The Angels were created from light and the Jinn from smokeless fire. (Saheeh Muslim)
It is this description of the Jinn which tells us so much about them. Because they were created from fire, their nature has generally been fiery and thus their relationship with man has been built upon this. Like humans, they too are required to worship God and follow Islam. Their purpose in life is exactly the same as ours, as God says:
I did not create the Jinn and mankind except to worship Me. (Quran 51:56)
Jinns can thus be Muslims or non-Muslims. However, due to their fiery nature the majority of them are non-Muslims. All these non-Muslim Jinns form a part of the army of the most famous Jinn, Satan[1]. Consequently, these disbelieving Jinns are also called devils. Jinns also become Muslims, as they did in the time of the Prophet, may the mercy and blessings of God be upon him, when a group of them were amazed by the recitation of the Quran. God orders the Prophet to tell the people of this event:
Say (O Muhammed): It has been revealed to me that a group of Jinn listened and said; Indeed we have heard a marvelous Quran. It guides unto righteousness so we have believed in it, and we will never make partners with our lord.(Quran 72:1-2)
In many aspects of their world, the Jinn are very similar to us. They eat and drink, they marry, have children and they die. The life span however, is far greater then ours. Like us, they will also be subject to a Final Reckoning by God the Most High. They will be present with mankind on the Day of Judgment and will either go to Paradise or Hell.
Thursday, July 28, 2011
Recent updates on the Golden Cow
Wednesday, July 27, 2011



Hi all! FInally done with the main roughing out of my story. I'll be going over quite a bit though. Do forgive me, I'm not at my illutstrating best at the moment - typhoon hit so I"ve been clearing trees and things for a few days. Quite happy that we have power back for me to post this week haha!
Open Questions: the collection of stories as a whole
Magic is often used in many of these stories. What kind of magic is it? What kinds of things does it tend to be used for? On a more general level, what is the relationship between magic and Islam?
How would you organize these stories in an anthology? Which stories go together and why?
Which stories do you think hold the most potential for illustrations? The least?
Have you encountered different versions of these stories? Can you describe which stories and the way in which certain elements were altered?
Do you see any common patterns or elements running through all these stories?
Open Questions: Hamda and the Fairy Fish
Compare and contrast this story with the traditional Cinderella story: what is the same? What is different? What is the significance of these similarities and differences?
I thought it might be useful to share an interesting passage from a book I'm reading titled, Folklore and Folklife in the United Arab Emirates.
In the chapter on Folk Narratives, the author, Sayhid Had Hurreiz, writes:
"It is quite evident that the previous story (which is a UAE version of Hamada and the Fairy Fish--in the UAE it is titled al bideha or "The Fisherman's Daughter") is one of the variants of the famous folktale Cinderella . . . As is known in folktale scholarship, no other story enjoys wider distribution or extensive public attention that Cinderella. Its various themes and motifs have been used in opera, in children's motion pictures, in children's story books, in advertisements and so on. Studies covering many decades of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries and extending over Europe, Asia, the Near East and the USA have been published on this story" (75-76).
Just food for thought . . . .
Open Questions: The Thieves and the Tree Trunk
Does Captain Abdulrahman respond to his wife’s fears appropriately?
Stories are often made to instruct as well as entertain: what is the entertaining part in this story? Why or how would it appeal to children?
What is your response to the representation of females and males in this story?
This story seems more modern than the other ones, doesn’t it? Discuss what elements might or might not make it seem more modern (i.e. closer to our point in history/time) than the other tales.
Open Questions: The Golden Cow
The Golden Cow is an interesting symbol in this story. Why a cow? What are some possible meanings here?
Remember that a symbol is something in the story that has meaning(s) beyond the literal. For example, in this case, is the cow just a cow, nothing more? Is the cow simply a convenient receptacle for hiding young, beautiful girls that wish to escape a dysfunctional home life? Or is there something more here? The library has a few symbol dictionaries in the collection: any takers?
Open Questions: Hassan and the Jewels
Who are the “good” characters in this story and who are the “bad” ones? Do some characters start out good and then become bad? What defines their "badness" and "goodness?"
What is the moral of this story?
This story is full of “rich” symbols. What are they and what do they mean?
Open Questions: Om Hamar (Donkey Lady)
Discuss the significance of the context: Garangao. Garangao seems to me like an Arab version of Halloween. Are there any cultural difference to take into consideration here? Is Garangao just like Halloween as it is usually understood in the west? Or are there some key differences to think about for western readers?
Many of the tales under discussion originate from other parts of the GCC. This one, however, is said to originate from Qatar. Is there anything in particular about this tale that marks it as undoubtedly Qatari?
The time period of the tale is circa 1930. Is this time period significant for some reason? In other words, why set the story in 1930 rather than 1900 or 1990?
Open Questions: Hadeed Hadeedoo
If we were to place the two main characters into "good" and "bad" categories, it seems obvious that Hadeed Hadeedoo is good and the witch is bad, right? Answer this question by examining closely the actions of each character in the story.
As in many of the other tales, magic plays an important role in this one. Who uses magic? What do they use it for? Who does not use magic? Are there times when magic could obviously be used but is not? Why?
Side note: a striking image in this story is the witch sharpening her teeth and ripping the young goat's flesh apart (an image that is repeated). Freaky.
Open Questions: Om al Manakhel
Fairy tales are often used as vehicles to transmit morals to children. If that is true, what is the moral of this story?
Morjana is recognizably a Cinderella figure. Compare and contrast this tale to the Cinderella tale. What is similar? What is different?
Is the woman in the road actually the old woman magically disguised?
Discuss the theme of magic in this story (and perhaps compare it to other stories): how is magic used? Is it used for good or evil? Both?
Why do stepmothers always seem to be innately evil figures in these tales? I know plenty of stepmothers who are nice, caring parents to their children, even if they are not are not biologically connected.
Open Questions: The Legend of Mai and Ghaillan
Does Ghaillian win the race in a way that is fair?
Mai is an interesting character in this story. Of the stories that we have, there are not many examples of powerful female figures. I was hoping that Mai would win the race against Ghaillan to show that women can beat men at their own games. Unfortunately, this is not how the story ends. In the end, the man wins again. How do you feel about the ending?
Many of our stories have unclear settings: "Once upon a time, in a land far, far away." This one, however, has a very specific and local setting: Al Khor. What is the significance of this local setting in the story? Why set this tale in Al Khor instead of Doha or Al Wakra or Dukhan?
Folk or fairy tales are often created with a specific moral or teaching in mind. What is the moral of this story? Is there more than one?
What do these stories mean?
I've generated some open questions in response to a close reading of the stories. I hope that responding to these questions will create interesting discussion, surprising discoveries and productive research.
Everyone should involve themselves in these discussions, especially the layout team. This is a valuable opportunity for the layout team to make an important contribution to the project.
I realize that the illustrators are busy illustrating, which is good: I do not expect you to respond in depth. However, I think the illustrators could really benefit from following these discussions and participating in them when they can. How one interprets the stories intellectually will influence how one renders them visually.
Because our team is so culturally diverse, we'll each interpret these stories slightly differently for we are each reading them through the lens of our own cultural values and beliefs: this is a good thing! Part of our hope in this project is that these stories will spark discussion between Qatari and non-Qatari in order to learn more about each others cultural frameworks and hopefully lead to more well-informed and empathic relations between these two very diverse groups.
Let me give you a quick example. In the Legend of Mai and Ghaillan, Ghaillan wins the dhow race against Mai through technological innovation. While a locust (a locust? Where I come from, a locust is a grasshopper and they do not buzz around our heads--only flies do. Is there something lost in translation here? These are the sorts of questions we should be posing and seeking answers to in our discussion--this question, obviously, influences the illustration, does it not?) is buzzing around his head, Ghaillan pays particular attention to the shape of its wing and is inspired to create a "wing" for his dhow, which helps him win the race (examining nature to solve human problems is called "biomimicry"). In my culture, many (but not all) would interpret this move as cheating. Although the terms of the race are never explicitly discussed, my assumption would be that both merchants are only be allowed to use a dhow, men, and paddles, nothing more. This is a fair contest. Introducing the sail gives Ghaillan an unfair advantage. Therefore, interpreting his character and the race through my own cultural values leads me to conclude that I do not see him in a positive light: he is clever, yes, but he is fundamentally a cheater. I don't think that the text encourages us to view Ghaillan in this way, which leads me to believe that a set of cultural values different from my own are at work in this tale. This should prompt me to conduct research of some form to help explain this discrepancy.
I will create a separate post for each set of questions for each story so that we can keep things organized. Feel free to respond to my questions or, even better, pose and seek answers to your own. The questions I've generated are simply a place to begin.
You can read the text of the stories on the blog. They are located in various places. You'll have to search through older posts to find them.
I'm excited to get the discussions going. I think they will be very enlightening. Good luck!
Thursday, July 21, 2011



Hello again. Here are more roughs for you. I do apologize, I'm a bit behind my own schedule. Hopefully you'll see the end of these drawings as they and get more refinement in but it's progressing still.
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
Welcome to Abdulla Al Kuwari!
Sources
Storytelling, Folktales and the Comic Book Format, Gail de Vos
Graphic novels for multiple literacies, Gretchen E. Schwarz
Image, Text and Story: Comics and Graphic Novels in the Classroom, Rachel Marie-Crane Wiliams
How Comic Books Can Change the Way Our Students See Literature: One Teacher's Perspective, Rocco Versaci
Marveling at The Man Called Nova: Comics as Sponsors of Multimodal Literacy: Dale Jacobs
Multi Cultural Literacy and Folk Tales
http://people.hofstra.edu/alan_j_singer/Education/Muti%20Literacy%203.pdf
Teaching Similar and Different through Folk Tales
http://www.tip.sas.upenn.edu/curriculum/units/2010/05/10.05.07.pdf
Cultural Success of Folktales (abstract)
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1207/s15516709cog0000_68/abstract
Folk tales and literacy
http://eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/search/detailmini.jsp?_nfpb=true&_&ERICExtSearch_SearchValue_0=ED488980&ERICExtSearch_SearchType_0=no&accno=ED488980
Folktales as Edutainment
http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1348225
http://www.intechopen.com/source/pdfs/10963/InTech-Promoting_socio_cultural_values_through_storytelling_using_animation.pdf
Folktales Lessons from Around the World
http://www.chatham.edu/pti/curriculum/units/2004/Tuckfelt.pdf
Tuesday, July 19, 2011
Monday, July 18, 2011
Om al Manakhel: Storyboard/Script Breakdown.
Hello Team. Broke up the script into sections based on action/plot/expression to decide on what & how to portray every scene/panel. Working on step 2: Illustrating the 7 sections into storyboards. Click image for clearer view.Sunday, July 17, 2011
Mai w Ghailan_02




Color scheme experimentation.
Thursday, July 14, 2011



Hello again, here are three more pages roughed out. They illustrate the scenes of the goat fleeing to the melon feild to hide, and outsmarting the witch again.
Wednesday, July 13, 2011
Mai w Ghailan_01
Friday, July 8, 2011
The Legend of Mai and Ghaillan
Thursday, July 7, 2011


Hi guys, put together the rough version of two pages. Still many scenes to do of course but while that's going on I'm trying to figure out how it will all come together.
Sunday, July 3, 2011
Zoe | H. and the Jewels

















